Might be a be dark Ken but the top one is the one I’d prefer out of the two.Lighten up the vignette and the darkness a little, as it has the makings of something nice. Its always good to try something new.
I like the first one best as well. I like boats. They make great subjects and these have also given you a good arty reflection. Quite a relaxing peaceful shot you can look at for ages. I also like the positions of the boats that become one form.
I read a good techinque for generating mist in photoshop is to create a new layer, dab some soft greyish blobs for your mist. Apply the ‘render cloulds’ filter, then play around with the layer blend options until you find one that works. It’s a bit hit and miss and you have to experiment a bit until it’s right for your main subject.