Robertshaw Trophy

Forums Crewe PS Business Robertshaw Trophy

This topic contains 6 replies, has 5 voices, and was last updated by Profile photo of ex-member ex-member 5 years, 2 months ago.

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #1149
    Profile photo of meg cumming
    meg cumming
    Participant

    Ok I’ll kick it off for the club. Well done to a good night all round. Not just because we won,but the fact that we had a judge who spoke with authority on the subject. I think Tom put it well when he said that looking over the images beforehand made for a better appraisal rather than on the night judging. Mr T. Kleinhans was an eloquent speaker and judge and marked fairly,I thought. I don’t know what anybody else thought, though from general comments the night seemed to be far fairer and critcally successful. So once again well done to all those who competed, you did your clubs proud.

    #1150
    Profile photo of D. Williams
    D. Williams
    Participant

    I agree Meg.  A really good evening.  The constructive criticism and attention to detail made possible because the judge had spent time and studied the image made such a difference.  It was a very high standard and nice to see so many creative images appreciated by a quality judge. I loved the lady psycho!  I also do think that tone mapping and HDR is becoming far more acceptable and we all ( well … those who like that sort of thing ) should brush up on our techniques a little.

    • This reply was modified 5 years, 2 months ago by Profile photo of D. Williams D. Williams.
    #1154
    Profile photo of Tom Seaton
    Tom Seaton
    Participant

    Yes a great success all round. None of our images scored less than 15 and the killers were the two 20s by Ian and Darren. Leek always run us close and I thought they would just sneak it especially when it came down to scoring the lady phycho. She got 18 and we made it by 2 points!

    Tillman was his usual brilliant self. In depth analysis of technique and creativity, amply and convincingly justifying the marks he gave every time. He’s in demand a lot and we have to book him early.

    The apprentice projectionists were brilliant with scarcely a blip noticeable.

     

    #1155
    Profile photo of ex-member
    ex-member
    Participant

    What a great judge liked and understood all he said. Would be nice to show him some of my stuff just to get some comments

    #1217
    Profile photo of Paul Hill
    Paul Hill
    Participant

    Hello, finally got a few minutes spare to be able to add a few comments on the forum.

    I agree with all the above comments. I’ve seen Tillman judge about three times now and he has to be, in my opinion,  one of the best judges on the ‘circuit’.

    He doesn’t seem to miss anything in an image. He will, as Dolores mentioned give the ‘Constructive criticism’ when needed.

     

    #1218
    Profile photo of Paul Hill
    Paul Hill
    Participant

    Right, next job,  I need to get an Avatar sorted !!!!

    #1229
    Profile photo of ex-member
    ex-member
    Participant

    Yes you do lol

Viewing 7 posts - 1 through 7 (of 7 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.